Author Hub | A Guide to Peer Reviewing Journal Articles 5/12 Before you review The following steps have usually taken place before you are asked to review an article: Author submits an article to their chosen journal using an online system, or occasionally directly to the editor. The editorial office will check that the article complies Doi: /h General Information: A peer-reviewed journal article has the following major sections: Title page, Abstract, Introduction, Methods, Results, Discussion, References, Table and Figures. The abstract for this article is a summary statement that highlights the information in the Introduction, Methods, Results, and Discussion sections of this research article readers of a designated journal. Choose a target journal and write to its readers. Visit your target journal’s websiteand investigate the journal’s readership. If you are writing for a journal with a more general readership, like PLOS ONE, you should include more background information. A narrower journal Author: Clara Busse, Ella August
How to Write and Publish a Research Paper for a Peer-Reviewed Journal | SpringerLink
Last Updated: April 12, References Approved. This article was co-authored by our trained team of editors and researchers who validated it for accuracy and comprehensiveness. wikiHow's Content Management Team carefully monitors the work from our editorial staff to ensure that each article is backed by trusted research and meets our high quality standards. wikiHow marks an article as reader-approved once it receives enough positive feedback, how to write a peer reviewed journal article.
This article has been viewedtimes. Learn more Skim the article to get a feel for its organization, read it multiple times, and jot down notes and comments during the process. Evaluate the text section by section, and assess how well each component fulfills its purpose. Come up with a thesis that concisely summarizes your evaluation, compose your review, and include specific examples that back up your claims. Read the article once to get a general idea of what it says, then read it through again and make detailed notes.
You should focus on things like whether the introduction gives a how to write a peer reviewed journal article overview of the topic, whether the writing is concise, and whether the results are presented clearly. Back up your points with examples in the main body of your review, which will make it more credible. You should also how to write a peer reviewed journal article your thesis about the article is clear by mentioning it in the introduction and restating it in the conclusion of your review.
For tips on how to edit your review before publication, keep reading! Did this summary help you? Yes No. Log in Social login does not work in incognito and private browsers.
Please log in with your username or email to continue. wikiHow Account. No account yet? Create an account. Community Dashboard Write an Article Request a New Article More Ideas Edit this Article. Courses New Tech Help New Expert Videos About wikiHow Pro Upgrade Sign In. Home Random Browse Articles Courses New About wikiHow Easy Ways to Help Approve Questions Fix Spelling Quiz App More Things to Try We use cookies to make wikiHow great. By using our site, you agree to our cookie policy.
Cookie Settings. wikiHow is where trusted research and expert knowledge come together. Learn why people trust wikiHow. Categories Education and Communications Writing Critical Reviews How to Review a Journal Article. Download Article Explore this Article parts. Related Articles. Article Summary. Co-authored by wikiHow Staff Last Updated: April 12, References Approved.
Part 1 of For example, a journal might require you to recommend an article for publication, meet a certain word count, or provide revisions that the authors should make. Skim the article to get a feel for its organization. First, look through the journal article and try to trace its how to write a peer reviewed journal article. Read the title, abstract, and headings to get a feel for how the article is organized.
In this initial, quick skim, identify the question or problem that the article addresses. Give the article a quick, once-over read. After a quick skim, read the article from beginning to end to develop an overall impression. Reread the article and take notes. After reading it in full, scrutinize the article section by section. You can print out a copy and write notes and comments in the margins. If you prefer working with a digital copy, write your notes and comments in a word document.
Part 2 of Decide how well the abstract and introduction map out the article. Examine the abstract and introduction in detail. Ask yourself the following: How well does the abstract summarize the article, the problem it addresses, its techniques, results, and significance?
For example, how to write a peer reviewed journal article, you might find that an abstract describes a pharmaceutical study's topic and skips to results without discussing the experiment's methods with much detail. Does it clearly lay out the groundwork?
A good introduction gives you a clear idea of what to expect in the coming sections. It might state the problem and hypothesis, briefly describe the investigation's methods, then state whether the experiment proved or disproved the hypothesis.
Most journal articles include a review of existing literature early on and, throughout, cite previous scholarly work. Determine if the sources it references are authoritative, how well its literature review summarizes sources, and whether the sources situate the article in a field of research or simply drop well-known names.
A good literature review will say something like, "Smith and Jones, how to write a peer reviewed journal article, in their authoritative study, demonstrated that adult men and women responded favorably to the treatment. However, no research on the topic has examined the technique's effects and safety in children and adolescents, which is what we sought to explore in our current work. Examine the methods. Assess how the article presents data and results.
How to write a peer reviewed journal article whether tables, diagrams, legends, how to write a peer reviewed journal article, and other visual aids effectively organize information. Do the results and discussion sections clearly summarize and interpret the data? Are tables and figures purposeful or redundant? Evaluate non-scientific evidence and analyses. For non-scientific articles, decide how well the article presents the evidence that supports its argument. Is the evidence relevant, and does the article convincingly analyze and interpret the evidence?
Assess the writing style. Evaluate style by asking yourself the following: Is the language clear and unambiguous, or does excessive jargon interfere with its ability to make an argument? Are there places that are too wordy? Can any ideas be stated in a simpler way?
Are grammar, punctuation, and terminology correct? Part 3 of Outline your review. Look over the notes you took in your section-by-section evaluation. Come up with a thesis, then outline how you intend to support your thesis in the body of your review. Include specific examples that reference the strengths and weaknesses that you noted in your evaluation.
Point out both strengths and weaknesses, and propose alternative solutions instead of focusing only on weaknesses. The body provides specific examples from the text that support your thesis. The conclusion summarizes your review, restates your thesis, and offers suggestion for future research. Revise your draft before submitting it. After writing your first draft, check for typos and make sure your grammar and punctuation are correct. Try to read your work as if you were someone else.
Is your critique fair and balanced, and do the examples you included support your argument? If possible, have someone familiar with the topic read your draft and offer feedback. Tom De Backer. As long as you have new information to add, and no longer than you can keep your readers interested, how to write a peer reviewed journal article.
If you have ten things to say, then you will need ten sentences to say it in. But if seven of those are boring, chuck them out and say just the three remaining. Cut any text down to the briefest way of wording everything without losing any valuable information. Not Helpful 2 Helpful If it's relevant. Not Helpful 0 Helpful 5. Include your email address to get a message when this question is answered. Submit a Tip All tip submissions are carefully reviewed before being published.
Related wikiHows How to. How to. About This Article. Co-authored by:.
Peer Review in 3 Minutes
, time: 3:16How to Critique a Research Article | Ausmed
1/18/ · By definition, a peer reviewed journal is simply one that contains material that has been reviewed by individuals considered to be experts in a particular field of study. These peer reviewed articles, also known as refereed articles, must meet specific standards set by publishers as well as undergo examination and possible revisions by 'peers' or other researchers in the field readers of a designated journal. Choose a target journal and write to its readers. Visit your target journal’s websiteand investigate the journal’s readership. If you are writing for a journal with a more general readership, like PLOS ONE, you should include more background information. A narrower journal Author: Clara Busse, Ella August 4/30/ · In the online resource 1, we also include an annotated journal article that identifies the key elements and writing approaches that we detail here. Before you begin your research, make sure you have ethical clearance from all relevant ethical review boards. Select a Target Journal Author: Clara Busse, Ella August
No comments:
Post a Comment